Casa Della Mozzarella Italian Deli: Authentic Italian Flavors in the Bronx

If you’re anywhere near Arthur Avenue and don’t stop here, you’re doing New York wrong. Casa Della Mozzarella is tiny, packed wall-to-wall with Italian imports, and home to what might be the freshest mozzarella you’ll ever put in your mouth. The sandwich I had was delicious prosciutto layered with mozzarella, a drizzle of balsamic, and just the right chew on the bread to have you wanting more. It’s one of those sandwiches where you take the first bite and immediately stop talking because your brain needs a second to process how good it is. Everything tastes artisan, balanced, and deeply satisfying, like someone’s grandma made it with love in the back. Highly recommend for the experience alone!

What the hell is the magic they put on their sandwiches!! Old school New York Italian deli literally makes the perfect sandwich!! Get the Bronx Bomber and get a trip to Sandwich heaven!! Treated us great with an extra sample of their house pulled mozz… No one does it like Casa Della Mozarella

Casa Della Mozzarella—A Bronx Institution That Demands Your Pilgrimage Tucked away in the Arthur Avenue area of the Bronx, Casa Della Mozzarella is the kind of place that makes you understand why people talk about New York delis with reverence. Getting to your sandwich is a rite of passage. The narrow corridor is packed with people squeezing past each other, hanging salamis overhead, and the chaotic energy of a place that knows exactly what it’s doing. You have to earn this meal. I ordered The Casa: prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, sun-dried peppers, and balsamic glaze on a classic Italian sub roll. The bread was phenomenal. The prosciutto was paper-thin, delicately sweet and salty, with that silky texture that melts on your tongue. The mozzarella was pillowy perfection, clean buttery notes, and just the right amount of salt. And that balsamic glaze? Thick, velvety, darkly sweet with a fruity tang. It’s more than reasonably priced for the little piece of heaven you get. If you’re in the Bronx, Casa Della Mozzarella isn’t optional. It’s mandatory.

Old world experience. The Casa was fantastic. From the bread, the mutz, the prosciutto, sun-dried tomatoes, and the balsamic. Heavenly, perfection. Small/narrow shop. Went early on a Sunday (930am-ish). No line, 5 mins. Love they are open in the AM. Definitely will stop in whenever I'm in the area to try out the other items on the menu.

Dear lord man, what a sandwich (I got the La Casa sandwich on ciabatta). One of the best I can recall ever having. This place transports you back to old-world NY in the best way.

Omg, Italian deli. I wasn't ready and missed the sandwich menu which is hanging from the ceiling behind all of their other amazing offerings. But i managed to eek out a decent order of a hero with mortadella, sun dried tomatoes, red peppers and fresh mozzarella...... it was nuts. Hella good sandwich, got some goat cheese, and a pesto sauce. Thr brah on my sandwich was crispy, held up and was easy to eat. Stoked to go back and order off the menu. Totally staying on the map.

Great sandwiches, I went twice during my stay in New York. The service is super friendly and attentive. The portions are very generous, one sandwich serves up to two people. I suggest grabbing a sandwich and going to Ciccarone Park, which is a one-minute walk away. cheaper and tastier than many things in NYC.

This truly is the place! I go to school in NYC, and a friend of mine at Fordham took me here last summer, he raved about the sandwiches said they were the best he’d had. I absolutely agreed with him after trying one, they’re wonderful here. All the employees are friendly and helpful, the atmosphere inside is great, and yesterday, I waited in line for just a sandwhich and they included a little bit of free, fresh mozzarella cheese that was easily the best I’ve ever had. If you’re in the Bronx, I’d highly recommend.